Beis shammai ruled that the lights should be lit in descending order eight lights on the first night, decreasing each night, while beis hillel ruled that the lights should be lit in ascending order beginning with one light on the first night and increasing. Hillel also known as hillel the elder is one of the bestknown sages of the talmud. Tzvi hirsch morgenstern, ateret tzvi chanukah 5669, notes that beit shammai prefer to highlight the strength of the miracle of chanukah, the defeat of the enemy. Shammai states that you light all eight candles on the first night, and subtract one each night. Hillels partner shammai, also a paragon of virtue, taught, greet every person with a cheerful face. This commitment to growing in hope and in power explains why we light the chanukah candles the way we do today. On the first day one lights eight and from then on one continues to decrease, and bet hillel says. He was also a fearless upholder of the torahs honor, standing up to herod and brooking no mockery of judaism. According to the tzemach tzedek, bais hillel would also agree with bais shammai that the chanukah candles should be patterned after the bulls of sukkos, but is of the opinion that the principle of maalin bakodesh overrides this similarity. The talmud records that the school of shammai and the school of hillel disputed the order of the number of lights on the chanukah menorah. Starting with one light the first night and working up to eight on the last, those lighting their menorahs with candles go through a total of thirtysix candles.
In a generation of saints and scholars, hillel and shammai were preeminent figures. Interestingly enough, though, there is a dispute in the talmud between beit shammai and beit hillel whether to increase the number of candles each day from one to eight, or to start with eight and remove a candle each day for eight days. Generally, shammai was a strict interpreter of halacha, jewish law, and hillel tended to be more lenient. On chanukah, we light a menorah to celebrate the miracle of the maccabees victory over their assyrian oppressors, and to celebrate a single jar of oil lasting for eight nights. In the babylonian talmud, tractate shabbat 21b, hillel and shammai debated the correct way to light the chanukah menorah. Shammai believed that we should light eight candles. Hillel believed that we should light one candle on the first night, two on the second night, etc. Nov 30, 2018 25 questions about hanukkah, answered. This paragraph is said each night, after the first light has been kindled. Hillels insightful reply whatever is hateful to you dont do to your brother, this is the whole torah. The ninth candle holder, which is set apart from the rest of the candles, holds the. How to light the menorah light up your environment. The students of hillel insisted upon starting with one candle and then adding one more each night.
Eight candles, and the halakha is like the house of hillel. Traditional blessings in hebrew are said before the candles are lit. Halakic legal controversies between bet hillel, bet shammai and jesus. Hillel and shammai on why we light the chanukah candles duration.
Shammai posited that we begin with all the candles lit and then put one out every night. Therefore, mehadrin min hamehadrin is performed to highlight the diminishing strength of the. As we know, we follow the opinion of beis hillel, which is to begin with one and add on a candle each successive night. I would suggest that shammai is following his general. Ner mitzvah colorful chanukah candles standard size fits most menorahs premium quality wax assorted colors 44 count for all 8 nights of hanukkah 4. He lived during the last century before the common era, served as head of the sanhedrin, the ancient rabbinic tribunal, and was the founder of the house of hillel beit hillel in hebrew, a school of jewish law famous for its disputes with the rival house of shammai. One midrash states that chanukah was to be regarded as an acronym for chet nerot vehalakhah kbet hillel eight candles and the law according to the house of hillel, referring to hillels view that we should light one candle on the first night and increase the amount by one every day shammai, on the other hand. Sunday, december 9th, lighting the 8th and last candle 5. Talmud shabbat 21b the hillel vs shammai debate on lighting chanukah candles. Shammai says that we should start with eight candles the first night and then light seven the second, and so on.
Volume 64, issue 2 talmud torah chanukah 5775 the bulletin. A deeper dive hillel and shammai were jewish scholars who lived in the first century bce, in the. Bu hillel has just the cure to cheer you up with 8 nights of chanukah celebrations for every type of student on campus. Every night of the holiday of hanukkah, also called chanukah, jews around the world light menorahs. Hillel and shammai two opinions ou staff june 29, 2006 the machloket, or disagreement, between hillel and shammai and their respective academies, beit hillel and beit shammai, in the matter of the lighting of the chanukah menorah, turns on a fundamental question regarding commandments, the performance of which varies with time. However, beis shamais view was that the candles should parallel the cows. The talmud continues to relate that there were those who wanted to perform the mitzvah of lighting the chanukah candles in an even more evident manner. In general, beit shammai s positions were stricter than those of beit hillel. Hillel says that we should light one the first night, two the second, and so on.
Hanukkah candles for lighting the menorah from basic to. Although we follow the practice of beit hillel, who argues that we should add another candle each. With the vision of harold and enid boxer ah, the orthodox union founded ncsy in 1954 to provide jewish teens with an opportunity to build a strong connection to their jewish roots through inspiration and leadership skills. During all eight days of chanukah these lights are sacred, and we are not permitted to make ordinary use of them, but only to look at them in order to express thanks and praise to your great name, for your miracles, your wonders, and your salvations. Zion judaica hanukkah candles hand made blue elegance deluxe 5. Hillel and shammai argue about the correct way to light the hanukiah. The menorah lamp in modern hebrew is the ninebranched candelabra used during the celebration of hanukkah, the festival of lights. Chanukah may also have historical affinities with the solstice in its later observance. Ncsy is a worldrecognized organization that has played a pivotal role in the lives of jewish teens across the globe. We are all familiar with the present method of lighting the chanukah candles.
Samuels we are all familiar with the present method of lighting the chanukah candles. Chanukah, and the academies of hillel and shamai by s. The mitzvah of hanukkah is a candle for a man and his household, and those who enhance mehadrin. Interestingly enough, though, there is a dispute in the talmud between beis shammai and beis hillel whether to increase the number of candles each day from one to eight, or to start with eight and remove a candle each day for eight days. Talmudic insights into chanukah chanukah ohr somayach. What most people are not aware of is that the talmud records a disagreement between the academies of hillel and shamai as to the correct method of lighting the candles. According to beit shammai, one should light eight candles on the first night of chanukah, and then one less candle each night, until the last night when one. Shabbos 21b in other words, ideally, according bais shammai, one should light eight candles on the first night, seven candles on the second night, and so on until the last night of chanukah on which a person lights only one candle.
This is a reference to the disagreement between two rabbinical schools of thought the house of hillel and the house of shammai on the proper order in which to light the. Rabbi hillel believed that we should light one candle on the first night of chanukah and add a new candle each night, building until the final night, when all candles are lit. Beis shammai argues that on the first night, eight. Every night, another candle is added, so that on the eighth night all eight candles plus one helper are burning bright. Since the original purpose for placing the hanukkah candles outside the house at its entrance was the public manifestation of the miracle, a house with two entrances required two sets of hanukkah candles. Hillel, however, said that you start with one light, then two, then three, and so on.
Hanukkah candles are burned to remember the miracle that occurred in the temple when one days worth of oil burned for eight days. Nine hanukkah candles including the shamash, which is used to light the other candles are placed in a ninebranched menorah candelabra. The debate between these schools on matters of ritual practice was critical for the shaping of the oral law and judaism as it is today. Happy chanukah temple beth david of the san gabriel valley. Ner mitzvah honeycomb beeswax chanukah candles standard size candle fits most menorahs premium quality pure bees wax 45 count for all 8 nights of hanukkah. This baraita lays out four different ways of observing the lighting of hanukkah candles.
Shammai said that on the first night, we should light all eight candles. Hillel s insightful reply whatever is hateful to you dont do to your brother, this is the whole torah. This occurred on the first day of chanukah and its impact diminished over time. The content on this page is for reference purposes only and is not actively managed. Beit shammai and beit hillel are, respectively, the eighth and ninth most frequently mentioned halachic authorities in the mishnah.
The school of rabbi hillel prevailed because holiness is something that must grow, not diminish. According to the tzemach tzedek, bais hillel would also agree with bais shammai that the chanukah candles should be patterned after the bulls of sukkos, but is of the opinion that the principle of. On the first day one lights one and from then on one continues to increase. Hillel and shamai had different views about the order in which chanukah candles should be lit. And generally speaking, legal interpretations tended to favor hillel. Now that the lighting of hanukkah candles was done inside the house, this was no longer necessary12 even for a winter room with two. Tzvi hirsch morgenstern, ateret tzvi chanukah 5669, notes that beit shammai prefer to.
Hillel was nasi,president shammai av beit din head of the court. Since the miracle of chanukah happened with olive oil the little cruse of oil that lasted for eight days an oil menorah is preferable to a candle one, and. The basic mitzvah of chanukah is to celebrate the miracle that happened then, by lighting the chanukia for eight days. Rabbi hillel maintains that one should start with one fire and increase each successive night until eight lights are lit on the eighth night of chanukah. On the first day one is lit and thereafter they are progressively increased each night. In their well known dispute, beit shammai and beit hillel disagree about the proper method of lighting the chanukah candles. The story of the covert who approaches hillel and shammai and asks to be taught the whole torah whilst standing on one foot. Beis hillel and beis shammai had differing views on how to light the chanukah menorah. Shammai said to start by lighting all the lights on the menorah on the first night and then light one less light each subsequent night. Chanukah december 29, 2018 all events are at bu hillel unless stated otherwise sunday, dec. Halakic legal controversies between bet hillel, bet. Take, for example, their dispute over how to light chanukah candles. And those who really enhance mehadrin min hamehadrin. Shammai said to start by lighting all the lights on the menorah on the first night and then light one less.
In general, the house of shammais positions were stricter than those of the house of. The basic elements of a kosher menorah are eight holders for oil or candles and an additional holder, set apart from the rest, for the shamash attendant candle the chanukah lights can either be candle flames or oilfueled. Recognizing our reality what are beis hillel and beis shammai really arguing about, when they debate whether we should count up or down in lighting the chanukah candles. The second level, called mehadrin, requires that one candle be lit for each person every night.
The students of one rabbi, shammai, believed that the celebration of chanukah should begin with eight candles, taking one away each night. Interestingly, the famous talmudic debate between beit shammai and beit hillel over the lighting of chanukah candles, recorded in shabbat 21b, reflects the same desire to find the universalistic message in this seemingly particular story. How to light the hannukah menorah and recite the hanukkah prayers. The talmud, in a famous story, contrasts the strict approach of shammai and the gentle approach of hillel regarding potential. The highest level, the mehadrin min hamehadrin, is a topic of debate between beis shammai and beis hillel. The story of the two fellows who betwager with each other a huge amount whether they can make hillel lose his temper.
In his view, beit shammais system has the candles represent the body and victory over the enemy who wanted to physically destroy us. One midrash states that chanukah was to be regarded as an acronym for chet nerot vehalakhah kbet hillel eight candles and the law according to the house of hillel, referring to hillel s view that we should light one candle on the first night and increase the amount by one every day shammai, on the other hand. The chanukah menorah also known as a hanukkiah is lit around nightfall each of the eight nights of chanukah. Some 2100 years ago the land of israel came under the rule of the syriangreek emperor antiochus, who issued a. Hillel s partner shammai, also a paragon of virtue, taught, greet every person with a cheerful face. Aug 14, 2007 hillel and shammai argue about the correct way to light the hanukiah. Beis shammai was of the opinion that we begin with 8 candles on the first night of chanukah and remove one each subsequent night. Eating latkes potato pancakes sufganiyot doughnuts and playing dreidel by the chanukah lights makes these eight nights a jewish holiday favorite.
Therefore on the 8 th night of chanukah one should light only one candle. Beis shammai argues that on the first night, eight candles are lit, and one candle is subtracted each. The menorah has eight branches with candle holders in a long line to represent the hanukkah miracle, when the oil that was supposed to last only one day burned for eight days. Eight descending days of light and eight ascending days of light would parallel the respective directions of the positions of beit shammai and beit hillel, shabbat 21a. A human rights commentary on chanukah a human rights commentary on chanukah rabbi shlomo ephraim luntchitz 15501619, in olelot ephraim, vol. Rabbi shammai, on the other hand, contends that we should start with eight lights on the first night, and then decrease each night to count down the days of chanukah, until only one is left. Hillel and shammai lived during the second temple, at the beginning of the era of the tannaim, the authors of the mishna, the core of the oral tradition. Hillel taught that, on the first day of chanukah, one candle ought to be lit and then one additional candle should be lit per day, until eight candles are lit on the final day. On the first day of chanukah, one lights eight lights. The academy of shamai said that we should begin with eight candles and on each successive night, light one less.
1614 965 738 1051 296 838 1358 1636 1151 935 837 526 842 171 298 1371 530 561 1351 1515 878 174 688 338 23 1517 180 181 1365 1456 1003 660 985 58 210 218